Apple’s new laptops: Ugly, unusable crap
I’m sure you couldn’t tell, but I’m not happy about Apple’s announcements today.
They’re Ugly
Really. These things just look bad. I hated the nasty black bezel on the aluminum iMac, and I hate it on these. It hasn’t grown on me. They’re plain ugly, eschewing clean minimalism for a terrible retro throwback design. I mean, we’ve been here before. What’s next, Snow White?
And why can’t they keep their stuff unified? The iMac and iPhone come out with the silver/black/gloss design, then the iPhone goes back to the MacBook style black/white, then they kill that design entirely. What are they smoking?
No Matte Screens
The only computer Apple sells with a matte screen is now the 17” MacBook Pro. I know that the mouth-breather faction just loves them some glossy, but they’re truly god-awful unusable crap. I’m sure they’re great if you’re sitting in your mom’s basement watching ST:TOS, but for those who need to use them outside an inky grotto, the gloss is a huge negative. Many people agree with me on this.
I mean, really. Look at this photo. It’s awful.
They’re Really Dumb
The Pro laptops have two graphics cards; one for when you’re plugged in and want to push as many polygons as possible, and one to conserve power when you’re on battery. Now, this sounds pretty cool, actually. It would be better if you had a single card that could just scale down, like modern CPU cores can, but it sounds pretty neat. Well, until you find out that to switch, you have to log out. Seriously. Log out? What is this, Windows? May as well require a reboot.
Let me ask you: when was the last time you logged out of your computer? Can you even remember? I never log out; it’s too big an interruption to my workflow. Macs have this slick sleep mode that lets you take them anywhere and never interrupts what you were doing. This breaks all of that, and I don’t even see the point of having a laptop that works that way. You may as well go buy an iMac to keep on your desk, since it’ll be faster to resume working there than log out and back in to your laptop.
For a company with a reputation of making things that Just Work™, this is a major screwup.
There’s no way I’m going to be sporting one of these things. I just hope my late 2007 MacBook Pro lasts until Uncle Steve’s recto-cranial inversion is reversed.



October 15th, 2008 at 11:55 am
[...] need to log out. Of course Apple users accustomed to usability of everything produced by Apple are perplexed by this approach and question its [...]
October 16th, 2008 at 10:44 am
Regarding ‘ugly’, I agree. I’m gutted. I really don’t like the new ‘I’m a PC’ look.
Regarding the new spec, I haven’t bothered to read about it. If I can’t face looking at them, let alone buying one, then it makes no difference to me how good or bad they are technically.
I have two previous macbook pro’s. Both are going strong. I was going to treat myself to a new mac laptop, but now I’ll stick with the superior previous model.
November 17th, 2008 at 9:59 pm
Dude, you are soooo wrong. I just bought one. It is a beautiful machine. I’m running Adobe’s new CS4 software to do graphic and web design, Maya 2008 to do 3D, FinalCut Studio for video and its all awesome. I’ve loaded Mathematica and Matlab on OS X for work. Under BootCamp I’ve loaded WIndows Vista 64 with Pro/Engineer Wildfire 4, Ansys 11 and Visual Studio 2008. Everything runs great on this platform. I love the fact that I can change video processors when I need to, and access Unix. I wish I had more time to code in Cocoa rather than .Net for work because the new developer’s tools run great on this machine too. The display is awesome and I think the sleek aluminum unibody case represents robust structural design married with simple elegance. Apple has nailed it. This machine puts my old powerbook to shame. Way to go Apple!
November 21st, 2008 at 10:57 pm
@Mysilmaril There are huge drawbacks to the new designs. Glossy screens just don’t work as well in the real world. Then there’s the DisplayPort to Dual Link DVI adapter. They’re delayed until late December (the 23rd), and they need a USB port to power.
The GPU flexibility is a good thing. The requirement to manually change the setting - then log out and back in - is pathetic.
Lame, lame, lame.
December 29th, 2008 at 12:44 pm
[...] the ongoing World of Fail that is Apple’s new laptops, the long-delayed Mini DisplayPort to Dual-Link DVI adapters don’t [...]
February 12th, 2009 at 3:09 am
You forgot to mention the stiffest and loudest touchpad ever produced by men.